Since there seems to be some question

Because I bowed out of the Litblog Co-op citing personal and other obligations, I can see why some people, including the proprietor of The Literary Saloon, would take umbrage at this section of Joy Press’ Village Voice article about book blogs:

Newton says she declined because she’s already juggling a full load among her blog, a novel in progress, freelance book reviewing, and her day job. But she also argues that “the Co-op does something like what the media do — it creates a big push for a book. If their goal is to prove the influence of blogs to publishers, I think they’ll succeed — but it’s not a goal I share myself.” Instead, she says she prefers the way ideas slowly percolate down to the reader, independent of publishing dates and industry agendas.

So I’d like to clarify a few things.

First of all, as I told Ms. Press, I support the co-op’s desire to support neglected books. Secondly, I plan to try every “read this!” selection. And finally, because no part of the Internet is a closed circle, I’ll be able to talk about my own response to each book at my own site — a more traditional book blog approach (if anything in the blog world can be called “traditional”) that will enable me to discuss the nuances of my reaction.

I don’t mean to imply that I was misquoted in the Village Voice article. I wasn’t, and I do mean what I said, but it seems important to observe that I was responding to a direct question: “do you think the co-op will be able to achieve the goal of proving to publishers that blogs can influence book sales?”

Judging from the flood of review copies sent to my door, I think publishers already know blogs help move books. The co-op should offer concrete evidence of that. But I don’t think that’s the primary mission of its members, many of whom I have known, online at least, and respected for several years now.


Newsletter Signup

Subscribe to my free newsletter, Ancestor Trouble.


You might want to subscribe to my free Substack newsletter, Ancestor Trouble, if the name makes intuitive sense to you.