Shteyngart and Lipsyte compare notes on the Lish method

Gary Shteyngart interviews Sam Lipsyte in a Queens drinking establishment for the Loggernaut Reading Series.

LRS: Were you a student of Gordon Lish [who nicknamed himself “Captain Fiction,” and contends he “played a crucial role in the creation of the early short stories of Ramond Carver”]?

Lipsyte: Yes, I studied with him. He published a couple of stories of mine in The Quarterly, after many rejections. They had that great form letter when they rejected you — it was about five hundred words long.

LRS: I was studying writing at college and then this professor showed up, a disciple of Gordon Lish, and we operated according to the Lish method. You start reading your work and then as soon as you hit a false note she made you stop.

Lipsyte: Yeah, Lish would say, “That’s bullshit!”

LRS: That process completely derailed me. Took me years to recover my voice. But for you it actually seemed to have some kind of benefit.


You might want to subscribe to my free Substack newsletter, Ancestor Trouble, if the name makes intuitive sense to you.